Skip to content

Framework

AI citation audit scoring matrix

A scoring matrix for separating AI citation access, retrieval, extraction, role, fidelity and stability.

CollectionFramework
TypeMatrix
Layertransversal
Version1.0
Stabilization2026-05-13
Published2026-05-13
Updated2026-05-13

Governance artifacts

Governance files brought into scope by this page

This page is anchored to published surfaces that declare identity, precedence, limits, and the corpus reading conditions. Their order below gives the recommended reading sequence.

  1. 01Definitions canon
  2. 02Site context
  3. 03Public AI manifest
Canon and identity#01

Definitions canon

/canon.md

Canonical surface that fixes identity, roles, negations, and divergence rules.

Governs
Public identity, roles, and attributes that must not drift.
Bounds
Extrapolations, entity collisions, and abusive requalification.

Does not guarantee: A canonical surface reduces ambiguity; it does not guarantee faithful restitution on its own.

Context and versioning#02

Site context

/site-context.md

Notice that qualifies the nature of the site, its reference function, and its non-transactional limits.

Governs
Editorial framing, temporality, and the readability of explicit changes.
Bounds
Silent drifts and readings that assume stability without checking versions.

Does not guarantee: Versioning makes a gap auditable; it does not automatically correct outputs already in circulation.

Entrypoint#03

Public AI manifest

/ai-manifest.json

Structured inventory of the surfaces, registries, and modules that extend the canonical entrypoint.

Governs
Access order across surfaces and initial precedence.
Bounds
Free readings that bypass the canon or the published order.

Does not guarantee: This surface publishes a reading order; it does not force execution or obedience.

Evidence layer

Probative surfaces brought into scope by this page

This page does more than point to governance files. It is also anchored to surfaces that make observation, traceability, fidelity, and audit more reconstructible. Their order below makes the minimal evidence chain explicit.

  1. 01
    Canon and scopeDefinitions canon
  2. 02
    Weak observationQ-Ledger
Canonical foundation#01

Definitions canon

/canon.md

Opposable base for identity, scope, roles, and negations that must survive synthesis.

Makes provable
The reference corpus against which fidelity can be evaluated.
Does not prove
Neither that a system already consults it nor that an observed response stays faithful to it.
Use when
Before any observation, test, audit, or correction.
Observation ledger#02

Q-Ledger

/.well-known/q-ledger.json

Public ledger of inferred sessions that makes some observed consultations and sequences visible.

Makes provable
That a behavior was observed as weak, dated, contextualized trace evidence.
Does not prove
Neither actor identity, system obedience, nor strong proof of activation.
Use when
When it is necessary to distinguish descriptive observation from strong attestation.

AI citation audit scoring matrix

This matrix evaluates citation quality across six dimensions. It should be used after basic access and page availability have been checked.

Dimension0123
AccessURL blocked or unstableaccessible with frictionaccessible and renderableaccessible, canonical and preview-safe
Retrievalnot observedobserved weaklyobserved across variantsstable across query cluster
Extractionno useful passagepassage vaguepassage usablepassage self-contained and scoped
Citation roleabsent or contradictoryornamentalsupportinggoverning
Fidelityanswer distorts claimanswer overextends claimanswer mostly preserves claimanswer preserves claim, scope and limits
Stabilityone-off observationinconsistentrepeated but variablerepeated across systems, prompts and time

How to use the matrix

Score the claim-source pair, not the page in isolation. The same URL can score high for one claim and low for another.

Output

The audit output should identify the weakest dimension and assign a correction type: access correction, retrieval correction, passage correction, source hierarchy correction or fidelity correction.

Use this matrix with the AI citation readiness checklist and the AI citation readiness audit.